Flaser wrote...
"The Key heroines are all in varying states of suffering, illness or death: indeed, this is the crucial moé point. It’s not enough that the girl is mentally unsound, physically weak, dependent, and perpetually shivering in pain: it turns out that for otaku, the most desirable woman is actually dying."
Well, that rules this entire cast out, then.
They're already dead.
[Some time later]
So, I'm done skimming those articles.
What the fuck.
Honestly, it seems that most of that article picks up on some rather offensive conjecture, and goes from there. I figure this probably isn't the place for it, but I don't think a quick dissection warrants a separate topic. Least, not yet.
Anyway.
So, the articles definition of moé is, quoted
Article wrote...
Moé, lit. “sprouting,” is a loanword from Japanese fandom, generally used to refer to characters or aspects of characters that elicit feelings of sympathy or adoration, such as personality or physical appearance, as well as related aesthetic styles. It is possible, for instance, to have a “cat ears moé,” or a “robot maid wearing thigh-high stockings reciting pi to thirty-six thousand decimal places moé,” but that sort of moé is not our focus. Crucially, when discussing the emotional aspects of moé, we inevitably address weak characters. Young girls are the most common subject of moé, though hardly exclusively so — Claudio from Ristorante Paradiso is a classic moé character, particularly in his passive, pathetic resistance to the heroine’s forceful courtship in the second episode of the series.
Now.
While the first bit, Sympathy or Adoration, is sort of on the money, somehow it fails to properly show me some correlation between finding Robot Maids in Stockings (Huh. Negima comes to mind.) moé and being attracted to weak characters. It's a completely separate attraction, no more unique then falling for a flesh and blood girl/boy with the same, or at least comparable, character flaws. To wit, I have quite a few bits of Tomoyo, Clannad Fame, and Rin, Fate/Stay Night fame, goodies. I, personally, find these two to be the heights of moé. I will laugh at anyone who insinuates that either of these two are weak, in any abnormal way...aside from that estrogen thing. But that's normal.
Beneath that, we have some more bullshit, capping in another annoying quote:
Article wrote...
“Have we [otaku] ever done anything entirely pure and beautiful without the whole thing erected on a toothpick-thin foundation of sexual hangups? [… D]o we really want a girlfriend, or do we just want a puppy? A puppy we can fuck, presumably.”
To wit, Otaku are not people. Otaku are slavering obsessives of some form of something or another. I'm going to ignore the common usage of Otaku, being that of the slavering anime fan, and instead use it in the original context, the slavering anything fan. I don't count those who cannot moderate themselves as proper individuals, but nevertheless. They talk, so I talk.
Rather, I'd more agree with Akamatsu's point, that moé is "strictly a non-sexual subject. Feelings of moé are often compared with an urge to “protect” or “mother” the subject."
Beneath that, and at this point I'm going to stop spoiler quoting, is a nice turd of bull. Apparently, no matter how emotionally or physically strong a character, at some point in their lives, they will feel an emotional undermining, "leaving them in the perfect position for a bigger, stronger, and more masculine entity to support them."
Right. Because men never feel emotionally unstable, and because the lot of us need not companionship anyway, because who need people they suck right?
I swear. While sometimes rather unrealistic (Read, Fictional), it would almost seem as if the character's are trying to be Human instead of Robot or Cardboard.
Haa~~
Let's see...what else does this fucker take shots at...
Aha! Tsundere!
Let's see. A Tsundere is classified as a..."Bitchy submissive"!?
...
There is so much wrong with that, I don't even..."This is likely because most fans of Japanese cartoons are similarly developmentally disabled, unable to handle a relationship with a mature adult, and find the attentions of a petulant child both non-threatening and attractive."...
...
Make of that what you will. I'm too disgusted for words.
"At her core, the tsundere wants nothing more than to be embraced by the patriarchal society that spawned her."
...You know. Like the rest of us.
Next is...
Imouto-moé?
Oh...boy. Well. I dunno what to say about this. I imagine some people do think of imouto moé in that way, but that's like saying some people look at their dog and have to suppress an urge to mount them/be mounted by them.
...Wait.
Hello. Code Geass reference?
I'm gonna cut this short. Things to do.
People to kill.