Complete and utter nonsense. After an episode like episode three, I expected a much better follow-up. I expect the writer to pull off something better than the nonsense that occurred in this episode. I may be unjustified in my anger, however, as I will express later in this review.
Allow me to get this out of the way: I was expecting this episode to have a
moment of heartwarming, like the last episode did and was largely successful at. It built pathos considerably well, and I felt that the writer very well projected Iwasawa's pain and relief unto the audience. That being said, allow me to continue my review, using categories that I believe are vital for a tearjerker story, as the writer has declared it to be.
OP & ED
I thought this was a brilliant move, and I likely should have expected the lack of resolution in this episode simply based upon the fashion in which the OP was molded. Very whimsical and made me smile.
The ED was also well done, as you may notice the changes in the character's positions as well as the noticeable absence of Iwasawa (she wasn't in the 3rd ED either).
Tone
Again, I should have expected the lack of clear resolution simply by the fact that the episode put on a very light tone from the get-go.
Build up for the main object
Unlike Iwasawa's past and Yurippe's past, this wasn't handled so well. I felt it simply glanced over the subject matter of Hinata's past, which I suppose should have been another indicative of the ending for this episode. However, the moment when Hinata realizes that
he really wants to move on is completely and utterly shattered by the moment that follows, leading me to neither laugh nor smile. It simply killed any sympathy that had been built for Hinata during the course of the episode.
Character Development
Close to none. The only thing made clear is that Hinata really feels that he would be happy to have moved on.
Accompanying Score
Not worth mentioning, as scores are best done in situations which require audience's reaction. This is simply an episode largely focused on comedy, and thus requires less a serious tune than a light-weight tune. Of course, the music playing in the ONE serious scene, in which Hinata is about to catch the ball, fit the emotion perfectly.
Connection in terms of series
I am so disappointed in this episode. It felt that the loss of Iwasawa was simply thrown out the window in order to provide a loli space to be boisterous.
Overall
This episode was not worth the wait that it held. I can understand that the writer might believe that a moment of funny to be necessary to counter balance the impact of the last episode. I can also understand that he might feel Hinata's character worthy of more elaboration in the following episodes. However, that is no excuse to make an episode that served almost no other than to contribute Hinata's cause into the pot of woes held by the characters. Now, I understand VERY much the necessity of having the audience identify with each character on an emotional level before dropping the heartshatterbomb, and this is probably the writer's plan (just look at Clannad). However, the main point is this: The episode, I felt, was lackluster and should have been placed and reformatted to fit elsewhere, somewhere further away from Iwasawa's passing on.